Last week I mentioned that Alex had officially begun preschool. I have to say that I'm in love with this school, not just because I think the teachers are well-trained and dedicated, or because they have a wonderful academic reputation, but also because of the general air of warmth and happiness that just seems to ooze out of the walls and the floors and grounds. It's exactly the sort of place that I would've loved to have attended as a child, and it's exactly the sort of place, I think, that matches Alex's exuberant spirit.
One of the other things I love about the school is that they also offer "extra-curricular activities." The school children are, at the oldest, 6, but the school provides classes in karate! And ballet! Last week the school provided lists to sign the kids up, and at a certain time every week, certified teachers from the area come to the school to teach the groups of children various activities. I scanned the lists and quickly signed Alex up for swimming lessons (she'd started taking swimming lessons a few months ago, and I thought it best to continue), and gymnasics, because I thought she'd find it fun.
This Wednesday was Alex's first gymnastics class, and as predicted, it was a resounding success. When I picked her up from school, she couldn't wait to tell me about all the forward rolls and jumping she'd done. "Really?" I said, as excited as she was. The director, who was standing with us, smiled. "Actually, Karen, this is the gymnastics teacher," she said, indicating a young man who was standing to her left. "Nice to meet you," I smiled. "How did she do?"
"She did great," he smiled back. Fantastic, I thought to myself. Enrolling her in gymnastics was a stroke of genius.
Then yesterday, as I dropped Alex off to school, one of the teachers who was at the entrance greeting the kids handed me a folded piece of paper. The school is very big on letting parents know what's going on at the school, so I assumed it was yet another newsletter. I smiled, waved "thanks!" and opened the letter as I was walking to my car.
Dear Parents, the letter began, we need to inform you, especially those of you who have children attending gymnastics, that Mr. Spotless Reputation, the gymnastic teacher, has been accused of child molestation.
I laughed at myself, certain that I had read the words wrong. I read them again.
My grip on the letter tightened as I realized that I'd read the letter correctly. I looked at the teachers, who had their hands full with all the incoming students. I re-folded the letter, and walked quickly to my car. I started the engine (and the air conditioner), read the letter in its entirety. Alleged incident occurred overseas, I read. Will not be allowed back on the premises until further notice. Parent meeting on Monday to discuss further options.
I drove to my local coffeehouse, stunned. Coincidentally, just a few months ago, I had my first no-one-is-allowed-to-touch-you-in-a-way-you-don't-want-to-be-touched-not-even-mummy-or-daddy conversation with Alex. I remember that at the time, I vascillated between trying to keep the conversation light, while simultaneously searching Alex's face for a sign of comprehension, of understanding. Karen, what are you looking for? I asked myself. She's only two. She's not going to get this. It's preposterous you feel you need to even talk to her about this. Nonetheless, I convinced myself it was never to early to start having this conversation, and besides -- it gets me in the habit of talking to her about things like this.
I was just surprised that it turns out I was right.
Once at the coffeehouse, I grabbed my cellphone and spoke to some friends, ones who I knew had children who also attend the school. We exchanged worried questions: what do you know? What do you think? What are you going to do?
Turns out that Mr. Spotless has been teaching gymnastics for a very long time, and is generally highly regarded as a teacher. The alleged incident involved a young teenager at a gymnastics camp overseas. Nonetheless, because of the long-standing business relationship the director of the school has had with Mr. Spotless, she trusts his denials, and felt that all options should be considered (with the children's safety being a paramount consideration, of course), including possibly allowing him to continue teaching, but under the close supervision of two additional adults (one of them being director herself). "The thing is," said one of my friends, "I've watched his classes before. And he's always so careful with the kids -- it seems he was particularly careful about touching them, often opting to simply gesture to them when he wanted them to do something. Who knows what the circumstances surrounding the incident are, but I have to tell you, he's always seemed beyond reproach to me."
I'll be attending the parent meeting on Monday to see what options will be discussed, but after careful consideration, I already know what I'm going to do: if he continues teaching the class, regardless of supervision, I will be pulling Alex from gymnastics. My reasons, actually, have nothing to do with my fear that something will happen to her -- I trust implicitly, with everything that I am, that the school will do their utmost to keep the children safe. It is clear that this is their number one priority (with the parents opinions and wishes being a close second). My reasons for pulling her have to do with the following:
1) Alex is not old enough to clearly articulate to me what's going on if, in the off-chance, something happens - a look, a strange statement , say -- that makes her uncomfortable;
2) Alex has only had one class -- she's really not going to know the difference if she's pulled, unlike other parents who have children with a long-standing passion for the sport. Besides, she's two -- we can always try gymnastics at a later date; and finally,
3) One day, when Alex is much older, the story of her gymnastics teacher having been accused of child molestation is bound to come up. And when that day happens, I don't want to have to look Alex in the eye and explain to her why I let her 2-year-old self continue to be in the presence of someone who was suspected of hurting children.
This last statement is actually 99.9% of the reason why Alex won't be attending if he continues to teach. Because after my obligation to keep her safe, I feel I also have a responsibliity to shoot straight with her. And in my mind, "shooting straight" includes ensuring, when Alex looks back on her life, she knows with all her heart that her parents not only always tried to keep her safe, but also did everything they could to respect her as a person.
I figure, as parents, it's the least we can do.